Popo union calls on Gray to hire still more cops, makes spurious claim about crime rate

April 12, 2012
By Phil N. Ferrill

More city union hubbub.  This time from the popo:

Lexington Fraternal Order of Police president Mike Sweeney says Mayor Jim Gray’s proposal this week to add more police officers is good, if enough new officers are hired.

“It’s a step in the right direction,” Sweeney said Wednesday. “But are they going to just keep manpower at status quo, or are they going to try to increase our authorized strength? I don’t hold out a whole lot of optimism for any large increase.”

The Division of Police said Wednesday that it is ramping up its current officer recruiting drive in the wake of Gray’s comments in his annual budget address on Tuesday. During his address Tuesday, Gray called for two new police recruiting classes and two new training classes for firefighters, in addition to classes already underway.

Just cause having a union is a democratic right doesn’t mean everything that unions say automatically makes sense.  In arguing that the city should hire as many as 200 more cops, the popo union said this:
According to Sweeney, Lexington police had 693 officers on the street in 2007. The city’s crime rate has risen by 21.5 percent since then, as police manpower has declined [to 505], he argued.
Speaking as an amateur social scientist, I feel pretty confident in suggesting that the jump in the local crime rate has had much more to do with this massive recession were in than officers leaving the force.  Given how expensive police compensation packages are over time, the city would probably get more bang for its buck using the money it would doing this on some kind of local jobs program or jobs stimulus until the recession ends.  Despite what some law & economics people have argued, I remain pretty unconvinced that there’s an easy correlation one can make between the police officer to civilian population ratio and the crime rate.  My sense is that it has more to do with the economy:
San Jose, for example, has 147 officers per 100,000 residents — the lowest among the biggest [California] cities — but also has the least amount of violent crime, with 383 incidents per 100,000 residents. Detroit, on the other hand, has 351 officers per 100,000 residents but also had 2,459 violent crimes per 100,000 residents.
Share

Tags:

2 Responses to Popo union calls on Gray to hire still more cops, makes spurious claim about crime rate

  1. Ricky Ravioli on April 12, 2012 at 11:46 am

    Can’t speak for now, but there was a time when Detroit cops were contributors to Detroit crime rates. Just sayin’. PS Does anyone remember Lexington crime fighter Andrew Thornton?

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  2. Danny on April 12, 2012 at 7:08 pm

    I’ve thought the same thing. The Bluegrass Conspiracy largely details Lexington crime-breaking cops (more than just Thornton) in the weed and coke trade (who mingled with the horsey set, and it seems, also Governor Brown) during the 70s and early 80s. When was the police benefits deal consecrated? Wasn’t it sometime around this era?

    It’d be interesting to go back in detail and look at how exactly Lexington cops got one of the best retirement deals in the nation.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

SUPPORT THE YONDER

Archives

Search

Social Networking Crap

Shop at the Barefoot and Progressive Store!

Free Ad Space

Help support B&P! DONATE!

Free Ad Space

Share Barefoot & progressive

Winner Winner Chicken Dinner

Stop SOPA

Switch to our mobile site